This is one of the most common questions asked by property managers. It’s a natural instinct. A full calendar feels like success. But when it comes to vacation rental performance, in our view a more useful question is: “How do I maximize total revenue?”

At the heart of this question is a critical tradeoff between occupancy (how many nights are booked) and ADR (average daily rate). These two levers work in tandem to drive total booking revenue. A strong pricing strategy isn’t about maximizing one or the other—it’s about finding the sweet spot where they balance out to generate the most income.

The Revenue Equation: Occupancy × ADR

There are multiple ways to hit a strong revenue number. You could have:

• High ADR, low occupancy: Fewer bookings at higher prices
• High occupancy, low ADR: Lots of bookings at lower prices

Which strategy is best depends on the property’s goals. For luxury homes or properties with delicate furnishings and premium amenities, it might make sense to prioritize higher ADRs and lower wear and tear. For more budget-friendly or suburban properties, maintaining steady occupancy may be the primary goal.

The key is being intentional. Revenue optimization means looking beyond raw occupancy and focusing on the total revenue you’re generating—and what tradeoffs are involved in getting there.

Illustrative picture below

The Pitfall of a “Full Calendar”

A full calendar feels good. But it can mask missed opportunities.

Imagine you’re booked every night in July at $350 per night. Great, right? But what if a more dynamic pricing strategy could have booked 70% of nights at $550?

The full calendar looks successful—but the second scenario might earn more revenue and reduce wear and tear.

We’ve seen real-world examples where:

• The average daily rate (ADR) more than doubled year-over-year
• Fewer nights were booked, but total revenue increased
• Booking strategies allowed for higher flexibility without hurting long-term performance

This is the essence of an active, dynamic pricing pricing strategy: making data-informed tradeoffs to improve overall yield.

Why Pricing Strategy is a Probabilistic Game

Unlike selling a product in a store, short-term rental pricing is probabilistic. You can’t perfectly know what would have happened if you’d set a different nightly rate or minimum stay.

Instead, you’re playing the long game—continually adjusting, testing, and refining.

It’s similar to poker: you won’t win every hand, but if you play smart, you can maximize your total winnings over time.

How to Use Dynamic Minimum Night Stays

One of the most overlooked tools in vacation rental pricing is the minimum night stay requirement. It’s a lever other than the actual nightly rate that can allow you to adjust and meet demand. Setting it too high can deter guests from booking. Setting it too low can fill the calendar with inefficient bookings that increase turnover costs and limit long-stay opportunities.

Here’s one example of how a tiered strategy might work:

• 180+ days in advance: 4-night minimum on weekends, 3 nights on weekdays
• 90–180 days out: 3-night minimum across the board
• Last-minute (<90 days): 2-night minimums to attract flexible travelers

This kind of setup allows you to attract longer bookings farther out, while giving flexibility closer to the stay date to fill in gaps.

Pro Tip: Use dynamic “orphan night” rules—if a short gap exists between two bookings, temporarily lowering the minimum stay can help fill it.

Smart Tactics to Reduce Vacancy

Of course, unbooked nights aren’t ideal. But they’re not always a problem if they’re part of a deliberate strategy. Still, you can work to reduce vacancy impact through:

• Empty Night Upsells: Offer early check-in/late check-out to increase booking value
• Last-Minute Discounts: Adjust rates automatically to fill nights close to today’s date
• Occupancy-Based Adjustments: If bookings are low, lower prices; if they’re high, raise them
• Dynamic Minimum Stay Rules: Allow shorter stays only where it helps (like filling in gaps)

Together, these tools form a dynamic pricing strategy that reacts to market conditions in real time—rather than setting a static rate and hoping for the best.

How We Do It at Vinifera Homes

At Vinifera Homes, we apply this kind of data-driven strategy across all our managed properties. We continuously analyze the broader market and key Sonoma submarkets to understand shifts in demand, ADR benchmarks, and booking behaviors. Then, we apply tailored pricing and stay-length rules based on that data. We also release quarterly reports on key submarket trends which you can find here.

Here’s what our approach looks like:

• Maximize revenue, not occupancy: A full calendar isn’t the goal—profitability is
• Use dynamic pricing tools: We rely on real-time data, not gut instinct
• Test and iterate: No pricing model is perfect. Ours is designed to learn and improve
• Stay active: We don’t “set and forget.” We’re hands-on and adjusting constantly

We understand that switching from a traditional model can take some getting used to. But this strategy consistently delivers stronger financial outcomes while preserving the long-term integrity of the home.

If you’re navigating these questions for your own property, the key takeaway is this: smart pricing is proactive, data-driven, and iterative. Whether you’re managing your home independently or with a partner, make sure your pricing approach reflects that.

Written by Anish Patel, Head of Owner Relations at Vinifera Homes (anish@viniferahomes.com)